Dawn Lowery 
7 Harsh Dog Training Methods Exposed
Dog training has evolved significantly over the past few decades, moving from dominance-based techniques to science-backed, humane methods. Yet many outdated and harmful practices persist, often causing more problems than they solve. These harsh training methods can damage the human-canine bond, create fearful and aggressive dogs, and even cause physical harm.
In this comprehensive exposé, we'll uncover the truth about seven of the most concerning harsh training methods still used today. We'll explore why they're harmful, what the science says about their effectiveness, and provide humane alternatives that actually work. Whether you're a new dog owner or an experienced trainer, understanding these issues is crucial for the wellbeing of our canine companions.
By the end of this guide, you'll be equipped to recognize harmful training practices and choose evidence-based, compassionate methods that build trust and create lasting behavioral change. Your dog deserves training that respects their intelligence and emotional needs.
What Are Harsh Dog Training Methods?
Harsh dog training methods are techniques that rely on intimidation, pain, fear, or force to control or modify canine behavior. These approaches often stem from outdated theories about dominance and pack hierarchy that have been thoroughly debunked by modern animal behavior science.
Evolution from Dominance Theory to Modern Science
The dominance theory in dog training originated from flawed studies of captive wolf packs in the mid-20th century. Researchers observed aggressive behaviors and created a hierarchy model that was mistakenly applied to domestic dogs. We now understand that wolf packs in the wild function as family units, and domestic dogs don't see humans as pack members to dominate.
Modern dog training has shifted toward evidence-based methods that understand canine learning through operant and classical conditioning. Positive reinforcement—rewarding desired behaviors—has been proven more effective and humane than punishment-based approaches. Organizations like the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior now explicitly recommend against dominance-based training methods.
Did You Know?
The original wolf studies that inspired dominance theory were conducted on unrelated wolves forced to live together in captivity, creating artificial social dynamics. Wild wolf packs typically consist of a breeding pair and their offspring, functioning more like a human family than a dominance-based hierarchy. This misunderstanding led to decades of harmful training practices that damaged countless human-canine relationships.
Common Myths vs. Facts About "Tough Love"
| Myth | Fact |
|---|---|
| Dogs need to know who's alpha | Dogs see humans as a different species, not pack rivals |
| You must punish bad behavior immediately | Punishment often creates fear without teaching alternatives |
| Some breeds need harsh methods | All breeds respond better to positive reinforcement |
| Physical corrections show leadership | True leadership comes from trust and clear communication |
| Dogs respect owners who are "tough" | Dogs bond with and obey owners they trust and feel safe with |
The 7 Harsh Dog Training Methods Exposed
These seven training methods represent some of the most concerning practices still used today. Understanding why they're harmful is the first step toward choosing better alternatives.
1. Shock Collars – How Do They Work and Why Are They Harmful?
Mechanism and Common Uses
Shock collars (also called e-collars or remote training collars) deliver an electric shock to a dog's neck when triggered by a remote control. The intensity can typically be adjusted from a mild tingling sensation to a painful jolt. They're often marketed for boundary training, barking control, or off-leash recall.
Physical and Psychological Risks
Studies show shock collars can cause both physical and psychological harm. Physically, they can burn skin, cause tissue damage, and trigger seizures in susceptible dogs. Psychologically, they create fear, anxiety, and can lead to aggression. Dogs often don't understand why they're being shocked, which damages trust and can create generalized fear of their environment.
The Evidence Against Shock Collars
Research published in the Journal of Veterinary Behavior found that dogs trained with shock collars showed more signs of stress, including lowered body posture and increased stress hormones, compared to positively trained dogs. Many countries, including Germany, Denmark, and parts of Australia, have banned or restricted their use due to animal welfare concerns.
2. Prong Collars – Are They Effective or Just Cruel?
Design and Application
Prong collars consist of metal links with blunted points that press into a dog's neck when tension is applied to the leash. They're designed to mimic the corrective nip of a mother dog, but with metal points instead of teeth. Proponents claim they provide quick, clear communication, but the reality is more concerning.
Long-Term Effects on Behavior and Health
Prong collars can cause physical damage including neck injuries, tracheal damage, and nerve damage. Behaviorally, they can create leash reactivity as dogs associate the pain with whatever they're looking at when corrected. They also damage trust and can create hand-shy dogs who fear reaching hands.
3. Choke Chains – The Dangers of Pressure-Based Training
How They Operate and Trainer Justifications
Choke chains are metal chains that tighten around a dog's neck when pulled and loosen when slack. Trainers often justify them as providing "clear communication" through pressure and release. However, the communication is often unclear to the dog, who may not understand what behavior caused the tightening.
Injury Statistics and Veterinary Warnings
Veterinary studies have documented numerous injuries from choke chains, including tracheal collapse, neck sprains, crushed tracheas, and eye injuries from increased pressure. The American Veterinary Medical Association recommends against their use, noting they can cause physical harm and worsen behavioral problems.
4. Alpha Rolls – Debunking the Dominance Myth
Origins in Wolf Pack Theory
Alpha rolling involves forcibly rolling a dog onto their back and holding them down, supposedly to show human dominance. This practice originated from misinterpretations of wolf behavior where subordinates would voluntarily roll over, not from forced physical manipulation.
Why It Erodes Trust and Increases Aggression
Alpha rolls destroy trust and can trigger defensive aggression as dogs feel threatened and trapped. Rather than teaching respect, they teach dogs that their owners are unpredictable and dangerous. Many dogs who undergo alpha rolls develop hand-shyness or become fear-aggressive.
5. Yelling and Intimidation – Does Verbal Punishment Really Work?
Psychological Impact on Canine Stress Levels
Yelling at dogs creates fear without providing clear information about what behavior is desired. Dogs have sensitive hearing, and loud voices can be physically painful and emotionally frightening. This approach increases stress hormones and can create anxious, shutdown dogs.
Studies Showing Fear-Based Responses
Research shows that dogs trained with aversive methods, including yelling, exhibit more stress behaviors like lip licking, yawning, and avoidance. They're also more likely to develop generalized anxiety and have weaker bonds with their owners compared to positively trained dogs.
6. Physical Punishment (Hitting or Kicking) – Legal and Ethical Concerns
Real-World Examples and Consequences
Physical punishment like hitting, kicking, or "popping" with a leash is not only cruel but counterproductive. It creates fear, damages trust, and often leads to aggression as dogs learn to defend themselves. It's also illegal in many jurisdictions under animal cruelty laws.
Alternatives to Avoid Escalation
Instead of physical punishment, effective trainers use management (preventing unwanted behavior), redirection (guiding to appropriate behavior), and positive reinforcement (rewarding desired behavior). These methods teach what TO do rather than punishing what NOT to do.
7. Flooding or Forced Exposure – Risks of Overwhelming Your Dog
Technique Breakdown
Flooding involves forcing a fearful dog to remain in a scary situation until they "get over it." For example, forcing a dog afraid of other dogs to remain in a dog park. The theory is that they'll learn the situation isn't scary, but the reality is often traumatic.
Trauma Indicators and Recovery Challenges
Flooding often creates more severe fear and can lead to learned helplessness, where dogs shut down emotionally. Recovery from flooding-induced trauma can take months or years of careful counter-conditioning. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior explicitly recommends against flooding in favor of gradual desensitization.
The Science Behind Why Harsh Methods Fail
Modern research consistently shows that harsh training methods are less effective and more harmful than positive reinforcement approaches. Understanding the science helps explain why.
Behavioral Studies on Fear vs. Reward-Based Learning
Studies comparing training methods consistently find that dogs trained with positive reinforcement learn faster, retain behaviors longer, and have stronger bonds with their handlers. A 2020 study in PLOS ONE found that dogs trained with aversive methods showed more stress behaviors and had higher cortisol levels than those trained with positive reinforcement.
Fear-based learning creates avoidance rather than understanding. Dogs may stop a behavior to avoid punishment but don't learn what to do instead. This often leads to "behavioral fallout" where suppressed behaviors resurface in other contexts or are replaced by worse problems.
Expert Opinions and Veterinary Guidelines
Major veterinary and behavior organizations worldwide now recommend against harsh training methods:
- American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior: "AVSAB recommends that training should focus on reinforcing desired behaviors, removing reinforcement for undesirable behaviors, and addressing underlying emotional states."
- American Veterinary Medical Association: "Training methods should not cause injury, fear, or distress, and should focus on reinforcing desired behaviors."
- International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants: "The IAABC opposes training methods that use pain, fear, or intimidation."
Comparison: Harsh vs. Positive Methods
| Aspect | Harsh Methods | Positive Methods |
|---|---|---|
| Effectiveness | Short-term suppression of behavior | Long-term behavioral change |
| Side Effects | Fear, anxiety, aggression | Confidence, trust, enthusiasm |
| Human-Dog Bond | Damaged trust and relationship | Strengthened bond and communication |
| Cost | Potential veterinary bills for injuries | Investment in treats and toys |
| Learning Speed | Variable, often slow with fallout | Generally faster with better retention |
Long-Term Effects of Harsh Training on Dogs and Owners
The consequences of harsh training extend far beyond the training session, affecting dogs' physical health, emotional wellbeing, and the human-canine relationship.
Health Issues: From Anxiety to Physical Injuries
Dogs subjected to harsh training methods often develop chronic stress, which can manifest as:
- Generalized anxiety disorder
- Suppressed immune function
- Digestive issues
- Skin problems
- Compulsive behaviors
- Physical injuries from training tools
Impact on the Human-Dog Bond
Harsh training damages the trust that forms the foundation of the human-dog relationship. Dogs may become:
- Hand-shy or fearful of their owners
- Less likely to seek interaction or affection
- More likely to hide behavioral issues
- Less responsive in emergency situations
Case Studies of Rehabilitation Success Stories
Many dogs can recover from the effects of harsh training with patience and proper methods. For example, a German Shepherd named Max who became fear-aggressive after prong collar training was successfully rehabilitated using positive reinforcement and desensitization over six months. His transformation demonstrates that even severely affected dogs can learn to trust again with the right approach.
Hope for Recovery
If your dog has been subjected to harsh training methods, there is hope. Dogs are remarkably resilient, and with patience, consistency, and positive methods, most can recover and learn to trust again. Consider consulting a certified positive reinforcement trainer who specializes in rehabilitation cases.
Humane Alternatives: Positive Reinforcement Techniques That Actually Work
Positive reinforcement training isn't just kinder—it's more effective. These science-based methods create willing partners who understand what's expected of them.
Step-by-Step Guide to Clicker Training and Treats
Clicker training uses a distinct sound to mark desired behaviors, followed by a reward. The process is simple:
- Charge the clicker by clicking and immediately giving a treat (repeat 10-15 times)
- Wait for your dog to offer a behavior you want to reinforce
- Click the moment the behavior occurs
- Immediately give a high-value treat
- Repeat, gradually adding a verbal cue once the behavior is consistent
Effective Training Tools and Management
Instead of harsh tools, consider these humane alternatives:
- Front-clip harnesses: Gently discourage pulling without neck pressure
- Treat-dispensing toys: Keep dogs mentally stimulated and engaged
- Puzzle toys: Provide mental enrichment that reduces behavioral issues
- Long lines: Allow freedom while maintaining safety during recall training
How to Transition from Harsh Methods Safely
If you've used harsh methods in the past, transitioning to positive reinforcement requires patience:
- Acknowledge that previous methods weren't optimal without self-judgment
- Remove all aversive tools from your training toolkit
- Focus on building trust through non-training interactions like play and enrichment
- Start with simple behaviors your dog already knows to build success
- Be patient—it may take time for your dog to understand the new system
Positive Training Resources
For more guidance on positive training techniques, check out our comprehensive guides on positive reinforcement techniques and humane crate training methods. These resources provide step-by-step instructions for building behaviors without force or fear.
How to Choose a Certified Dog Trainer: Red Flags and Recommendations
Finding the right trainer is crucial for your dog's wellbeing. Here's what to look for—and what to avoid.
Certifications to Look For
Reputable certifications indicate proper education and ethical standards:
- CPDT-KA: Certified Professional Dog Trainer - Knowledge Assessed
- CPDT-KSA: Certified Professional Dog Trainer - Knowledge and Skills Assessed
- IAABC: International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants
- KPA CTP: Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner
- VSPDT: Victoria Stilwell Positively Dog Trainer
Questions to Ask During Consultations
Before hiring a trainer, ask these important questions:
- What certifications do you hold and from which organizations?
- What training methods do you primarily use?
- How do you handle fearful or aggressive behaviors?
- Can I observe a training session before committing?
- What happens if my dog doesn't respond to your methods?
- Do you use or recommend shock collars, prong collars, or choke chains?
Red Flags to Watch Out For
Be wary of trainers who:
- Guarantee results or promise quick fixes
- Use or recommend aversive tools as a first resort
- Talk about "dominance" or "alpha" status
- Refuse to let you observe training sessions
- Use physical force or intimidation with dogs
- Blame the dog's "stubbornness" or "personality" for lack of progress
Trust Your Instincts
If something feels wrong during a training session, it probably is. You know your dog best, and you have the right to stop any training that makes you or your dog uncomfortable. A good trainer will welcome your questions and concerns, not dismiss them.
Conclusion: Building a Better Future for Dog Training
The evidence is clear: harsh dog training methods are not only unnecessary but counterproductive. They damage the human-canine bond, create behavioral problems, and can cause physical and psychological harm. As our understanding of canine cognition and emotion grows, we have both an opportunity and responsibility to train with compassion and science.
Positive reinforcement training isn't just "being nice" to dogs—it's more effective, creates lasting behavioral change, and strengthens the relationship between dogs and their people. By choosing humane methods and certified positive reinforcement trainers, we can create a future where all dogs are trained with the respect and understanding they deserve.
The journey toward better training starts with education and advocacy. Share what you've learned, question traditional methods that rely on force or fear, and always prioritize your dog's emotional wellbeing. Together, we can create a world where every dog has the opportunity to learn in a safe, positive environment.
Frequently Asked Questions
There's no such thing as a "stubborn" dog—only dogs who haven't been effectively motivated or taught what we want them to do. All dogs, regardless of breed or personality, respond to positive reinforcement when it's applied correctly. The key is finding what motivates each individual dog (food, toys, praise, etc.) and breaking behaviors down into small, achievable steps. If a dog isn't responding to positive reinforcement, the issue is usually with the training method, not the dog.
First, don't blame yourself—many people use methods they learned from others without understanding the potential harm. The good news is that dogs are remarkably resilient. Start by immediately stopping any harsh methods and tools. Focus on rebuilding trust through non-training interactions like gentle play, walks without pressure, and calm companionship. Consider working with a certified positive reinforcement trainer who can help you and your dog learn new ways to communicate. Be patient—it may take time for your dog to understand that the rules have changed.
While food is often the most effective reward, especially when teaching new behaviors, it's not the only option. Many dogs are highly motivated by toys, play, praise, or access to things they want (like going outside or sniffing interesting smells). The key is identifying what your individual dog finds rewarding. That said, food is a biological necessity, making it a powerful training tool. Rather than avoiding food rewards entirely, focus on using them strategically and phasing them out once behaviors are learned by switching to variable reinforcement schedules.
Modern behavior science indicates that there are no situations where harsh methods are necessary or preferable. Even in cases of severe aggression or other dangerous behaviors, positive reinforcement and force-free methods have been proven more effective and safer. Aversive methods often suppress warning signs without addressing the underlying emotion, potentially creating more dangerous situations. Organizations like the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior explicitly state that positive reinforcement should be the first line approach for all behavior issues, including aggression.
Look for trainers with certifications from reputable organizations like CCPDT, IAABC, or Karen Pryor Academy. A good trainer will:
- Use positive reinforcement as their primary method
- Welcome your questions and observations
- Focus on teaching you how to train your dog
- Create a customized plan based on your dog's individual needs
- Never use or recommend shock collars, prong collars, or physical punishment
- Be transparent about their methods and credentials
Always observe a training session before committing, and trust your instincts—if something feels wrong, it probably is.
Discipline comes from the Latin word meaning "to teach," while punishment means "to inflict pain or suffering." Positive discipline focuses on teaching dogs what TO do through clear communication and reinforcement. Punishment focuses on suppressing behaviors through fear, pain, or intimidation. Effective training uses discipline—teaching alternative behaviors—rather than punishment. For example, instead of punishing jumping, we teach and reward four-on-the-floor behavior. This approach creates dogs who understand what's expected rather than dogs who are simply afraid to make mistakes.
This common issue usually stems from moving away from food rewards too quickly. The solution is to follow a proper reinforcement schedule:
- When teaching a new behavior, reward every correct response (continuous reinforcement)
- Once the behavior is reliable, switch to rewarding unpredictably (variable reinforcement)
- Gradually replace food rewards with other reinforcers like praise, play, or life rewards
- Always occasionally "surprise" your dog with a high-value treat for known behaviors
Remember that we work for paychecks our entire lives—it's reasonable to expect our dogs to work for rewards too!
References and Further Readings
In the Spotlight
About the Author
